I-75 To Exit 191 Englewood/River Rd (Sr 777), Head South 5.7 Miles. Turn Right (North) On Us 41. Tortuga Community On Your Immediate Right. From Englewood: Take River Rd. To Us 41, Turn Left (North) On Us 41. Tortuga Is On Your Immediate Right. From Venice: South On Us 41 Towards River Rd., Tortuga Community Is On Your Left Just Before The River Rd. Intersection. Once In Tortuga On Tortuga Cay Dr., Turn Right On Balfour St, Then Right On Fishhawk Trail, Home On Left.